China's Lending Explosion

Is there anything wrong with China's lending spree. The central bank basically "advised" banks to ratchet up their lending, and the banks followed dutifully for the past couple of quarters with amazing results.

First of all, you cannot suddenly find so many attractive "borrowers" to lend aggressively to. Secondly, not many will say no when you offer to lend them money.

To be fair, this strategy pulled the domestic economy from falling further along with the ill effects of a global economy in crisis, but at what price. As I have mentioned before, this has to play itself out, and will not result in a sudden correction in property or stock prices in China. The liquidity rush will soon find its way into higher equity prices in China (hence bullish for the rest of the year for Chinese equity), and some may trickle back into Chinese property mart as well. Brace for high default rates when the music stops, probably after Chinese New Year in 2010.

China’s new lending more than doubled in June from a month earlier, increasing concerns bad loans and asset bubbles will emerge amid a credit boom.

New lending was 1.53 trillion yuan ($224 billion), the central bank said on its Web site today, bringing total lending this year to 7.4 trillion yuan. The calculation for new loans is preliminary, the central bank added.

The government is countering an export collapse by flooding the economy with money to fuel domestic demand. Rapid credit growth poses a risk to the nation’s lenders and a concentration of credit in some industries and businesses may damage the stability of the financial system, the banking regulator said yesterday.

Excess liquidity is fueling speculation and that means asset bubbles and wasteful investment. Already China recently failed to complete a $4.1bn auction of one-year government bonds, which suggested that investors are positioning for higher inflation caused by the credit surge.

Just something more to chew on, in 2005 Ernst & Young published a survey estimating that the bad loans in the Chinese banking system equaled close to $900 billion. Since then there has been enormous speculation in both the stock and real estate market. The average urban residential property prices fell by 15 to 30 per cent over the next two years from their levels at the end of 2008. Of course, by the end of 2008 they had already fallen from there 2007 highs. You cannot have real estate fall that much without having bad loans. Here is the juicy part, according to the prospectus for the Commercial Bank of China, it is illegal in China to foreclose on residential property.So what are bad loans? Bad loans = immediate write downs? No, they are then carried as what??? ... long term assets??? The reality is that no one knows exactly how bad the situation is in any bank. Information has value and is not disclosed unless required by law or for consideration. Since the banks in China are owned by the state, there is no legal requirement.


Something's gotta give ... but let's have a bull run first...

p/s photos: Elanne Kong Yuk Lam

China's Liquidity Traps & Benefits

China has been ramping up lending over the last 7 months. Yes, it was with good intentions. Yes, it was actual lending not just for show. Yes, banks in China were "asked" to do their bit to lend aggressively. While there is a lot of good to have money circulating around, it will also weigh down on those borrowing on the "unqualified" end of the spectrum, people who willing take on more debt than they should. Its a mini time bomb. No, it will not implode yet. What the figures below shows to me is that China's equity markets will have a major run up right through the end of 2009. When you pump in so much liquidity, there are very few places for it to surface. We may see a combustion effect only maybe in the second half of 2010.

China's credit card debt that was at least six months overdue rose 133.1 percent year on year in the first quarter to 4.97 billion yuan (727.67 million U.S. dollars), the People's Bank of China, or the central bank. Debt overdue by six months or more accounted for 3 percent of the total outstanding credit card debt at the end of March, or 0.6percentage point more than in the same period last year, the report said.

It warned of potential risks of the increasing overdue credit card debt as financial institutions expanded their credit card business. As of March 31, Chinese banks had issued more than 150 million credit cards, or 0.11 card per person, up 42.9 percent year on year. But Chinese consumers still have relatively few credit cards, compared with 4.39 per person in the United States and 0.95 in Brazil. Outstanding credit card loans rose 87.6 percent year-on-year to165.86 billion yuan at the end of March.

---

New bank loans in China will exceed 1 trillion yuan (US$146 billion) and may top 1.2 trillion yuan this month as the regulator expressed its concern over irresponsible lending, according to a newspaper report.

This month's figure may be the third-highest this year after March's and January's, the China Securities Journal reported yesterday, citing people it didn't identify. That would also represent a sharp jump from May's 664.5 billion yuan.

The news, coming in the wake of the central bank's remark on Thursday that it will stick to an appropriately loose monetary policy to support economic growth, sent bank shares higher yesterday on expectations of better profit.

Shanghai Pudong Development Bank gained 3.79 percent to 22.98 yuan while the Industrial and Commercial Bank of China, the country's biggest lender, rose 2.02 percent to 5.55 yuan, easily outperforming the key Shanghai Composite Index.

Earlier this week, the China Banking Regulatory Commission demanded that lenders avoid a sudden jump in loans at the end of each month and each quarter, a move used by domestic banks to meet internal targets.

The regulator told lenders to ensure the money is channeled to the right sectors such as small businesses to help stimulate the economy, and to monitor capital flow into the stock and property markets.

This month's lending surge was mainly fueled by mortgage loans and funding of government projects, the Journal said.

The new bank loans in the first five months of the year have reached 5.84 trillion yuan, more than last year's total and exceeding the government's target of 5 trillion yuan for this year.


p/s photos: Zhou Weitong

China's Growth Sustainable???

China has led the way by asking its banks to loosen the lending taps, and that has been reflected in the broader economy. China is an important export market for most of the smaller Asian countries. China's stimulus plan is a huge kicker, and the country has begun to stockpile a lot of soft and hard commodities. The black spot is that the easy credit has seen outstanding balances on credit cards more than doubled in the most recent quarter. Can China continue on its merry ways to lead the way to stimulate the rest of the world out of the recession?

• China's economy seems to have re-accelerated from the lows of Q4 2008 and Q1 2009 helped by significant government investment and credit extension. While exports continue to deteriorate, reducing the trade surplus, government investment has surged and consumption influenced by government investment is holding up, suggesting that that the Chinese economy may grow at a faster pace in Q2 and Q3 2009 than the 6% rate at the beginning of the year. However in the absence of new external demand and limitations on domestic demand, there is a risk of developing over capacities.
• In April 2009, many private sector analysts began scaling up 2009 estimates to the 7-8+% range from 6-7% range following the investment and lending surge and suggestions that the Chinese economy might be bottoming out. Now forecasters like the world bank are also doing so, if more cautiously.
• World Bank: very expansionary fiscal and monetary policies have kept the economy growing respectably with the country likely to experience a 7.2% growth rate for all of 2009. But China may not grow in the high double digits until the global economy recovers. Market based investment will lag, and despite resiliency, consumption will slow, meaning that the boost to growth may not carry through to 2010.
• In Q1, China's real GDP growth slowed to 6.1% y/y, the slowest in more than a decade and the seventh consecutive quarter of deceleration. Growth slowed to 6.8% in Q4 2008 from 9% for 2008. Several indicators (investment, stabilizing Manufacturing sector, robust consumption) began to show improvement by March 2009, indicating that the growth may accelerate in Q2-Q4 09 from the very weak pace and near stall of end 2008/early 2009.
• In Q1, Government stimulus boosted investment and consumption holding up despite a fall in real incomes. final consumption, investment and net exports contributed 4.3, 2.0, and -0.2 percentage points to GDP respectively.
• Goldman: More aggressive policy stimulus and stronger domestic demand response than previously expected suggests a growth will be 8.3% (previous estimate 6%) in 2009 and 10.9% in 2010 (9%) policymakers will eventually normalize and shift away from aggressive policy loosening, when they are more assured of a stabilization in domestic unemployment and external demand, giving additional insurance to the growth trajectory.
• The recent flood of credit-fuelled (and government-led) investment has staved off an economic collapse that might have sent unemployment surging and damaged the confidence in China's growth trajectory that is so important to its development prospects. However, it is a huge leap to go from this short-term success to declaring China to be out of trouble and back on the road to double-digit growth.
  
• Morgan Stanley: On a seasonally adjusted basis, the economy experienced a 5% rebound in Q109, after the first qoq contraction (-0.5%) in almost eight years. The aggressive policy stimulus should bring about further recovery in H209, making China among the first to emerge from the global downturn. The recovery should be relatively ‘job-rich’ but ‘profit-deficient’, especially in H109, with those exposed to government-supported capex programs likely benefiting most.
• BNP: In Q1, GDP rebounded as a result of the fiscal stimulus and the most expansionary monetary stance since 1997. Household demand for property and autos is rebounding while the credit surge is boosting fixed asset investment meaning China will achieve GDP growth of 7.7% in 2009.
• Citi: After seasonal adjustment GDP growth actually rebounded to 5.3% annualized in Q1, compared to 0.9% growth in Q408. The aggressive expansion in credit and investment seem to bank on a substantial rebound in final demand, or run the risk of greatly increasing overcapacity.
• HS: Given the prevailing external environment, it would still be a severe challenge for mainland China to achieve its 8% growth target this year and officials need to have exit strategies to prevent credit and money supply from expanding too rapidly to jeopardise future macro-economic stability.
• Even with the stimulus, China’s overall economic growth is likely to decline to around 5% in 2009. Although the country could potentially sustain higher growth, the poor outlook for exports over the next two years severely limits any quick recovery.
  
• ADB: Little evidence that China is rebalancing away from investment-led growth, but it is shifting investment sectors. Risk of entrenched inflation and overheating in some sectors

p/s photos: Zhang Xin Yu